A pastor's honest look at why our churches drift toward customers instead of disciples.

I have a confession.

I used to be one of those pastors who complained that unconnected people only want to be entertained—treating church like a product and themselves like consumers. I have sat in meetings and voiced that frustration out loud, thinking it a great many more times than I said it. Are our churches fostering authentic discipleship, or are we just striving to attract customers to improve the ministry's bottom line?

And then I started asking a harder question: whose fault is that?

The honest answer is probably not either/or. But here is what I have learned about myself and about the churches I have served: when times get tough and dollars are tight, you drift toward survival. And survival mode leads straight to a transactional ministry model.

The Cow and the Pig

In the context of the article “Disciples or Consumers? What Our Churches Are Really Building”, it is positioned right beneath the section heading "The Cow and the Pig" to visually accompany the discussion on transactional ministry versus relational discipleship.

When I graduated from the Seminary, our commencement speaker offered an analogy I have never been able to shake.

He said, "When you get into the parish, view your people as cows, not pigs. Cows you can milk for years. Pigs are only useful when they are killed for food."

I sat there horrified. This is my flock he is talking about. I am called to care for them and provide them with ministry — not to milk them and cast them aside.

But I have thought about that speech a lot over the years, and here is what bothers me most about it: it was not a slip of the tongue. It was a strategy. And strategies like that one do not stay in seminary chapels. They find their way into budgets, calendars, and staffing decisions.

The transactional mindset is an old sales philosophy, and it rests on four main tenets:

Value the transaction over the relationship.

Meet only the minimum expectations, or whatever the customer will let you get away with.

Advertise and "market" to people constantly.

Use persuasion as a tool to get people to buy.

Read that list again and ask yourself honestly how much of it describes the way your church operates.

Paul Hiebert put it this way:

"There are attempts at building deeper fellowship through small groups and church dinners, but few members are willing to pay the price for real community: involvement in members' daily lives and willingness to bear one another's burdens through sharing and financial assistance. When a church organizes itself using the social principles of a club, it soon becomes a club, no matter what it preaches about community."

That last line is the one I keep coming back to. No matter what it preaches about community.

When we reduce ministry to service-based transactions, our budgets fill up with programs, and we pray those programs are what our members — our customers — are seeking. Are those programs changing lives? Do they foster genuine discipleship?

This must be balanced with creating a culture and space for relationships, or our ministry becomes mainly service-provision driven.

When organizations lean into survival mode, leaders often need a structured roadmap to guide real transformation, such as Kotter's 8-step change methodology to help steer the cultural shift.

From Service Provision to Transformation

What if the question is different?

I know the word "transformation" makes some people nervous. But the biblical concept of transformation is not a mood or a personality type. It flows from a personal relationship with God, and it is a Romans 12 concept:

"Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that by testing you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and acceptable and perfect." — Romans 12:2

Notice what that verse assumes. It assumes something is being done to you and in you — not by you.

That is the whole core of authentic discipleship. The transactional model asks, 'What can the church offer me?' The transformation model asks, 'What is God doing in me?'

And I truly believe people want their lives to make a difference. Lives transformed by the power of the Gospel leave people asking different questions on their faith journey. Not "What can the church offer me?" but "What am I called to do for God?"

Imagine your church making that shift in their thinking.

Instead of your members looking to attract more people to fill the pews, imagine them looking for ways to build authentic community. Here is what that would look like:

Relationships that are cultivated over a lifetime.

A church that exceeds unconnected people's expectations and surprises them with genuine community.

A place among a group of disciples who understand and connect with people without judging their past brokenness and mistakes (Luke 15, the prodigal son; John 4, the woman at the well).

A community that shares and celebrates stories of transformation.

It is not that transactional is wrong. But transformation offers so much more.

So let me ask you

When you look at your congregation, are you building disciples, or are you managing customers?

Here is one place to start. Pull up last month's calendar and this year's budget and mark each line as either something that draws people in or something that actively shapes their discipleship. Do not worry about the exact ratio. Just notice which column is longer, and which one you instinctively protect when money gets tight.

The answer will show up in your budget, your calendar, and your conversations long before it shows up in your attendance numbers.

I would genuinely like to hear from you on this one. Where have you seen the transactional drift in your own ministry — and what did it take to turn it around? Reply to this email or leave a comment. I read every one.

About the Author: Rev. Dr. Keith Haney is an author, podcast host, leadership consultant, and executive director specializing in organizational management and leadership development. As the host of Becoming Bridge Builders and the author of Guided by Grace: A Narrative to Lead Organizational Change, he helps leaders navigate complex cultural and organizational transitions with wisdom, courage, and faith.